I'm a HUGE fan of Riu Chiu. And the Xmas Episode from the series isn't bad either.
But the idea that the Monkees would release a holiday, no-a CHRISTMAS album seems more than a little gratuitous.
And yes, I understand that the band was based on commercialism. Everyone and their brother does a Xmas album at one point, and really-wouldn't we rather hear THEM than yet another playing of "White Christmas" by Bing Crosby (or anyone else for that matter)?? But why NOW? And if they are going to do a follow up-or SERIES (??) of follow up albums to their record breaking release "Good Times" (2016), why would this one be a holiday album. Answer: because it will be purchased whether it is good or not-and lots of the hard hitting reviewers will give it a pass bc it is in the Xmas genre.
On Facebook, there have also been discussions of the track list, especially focusing on one in particular. "Jesus Christ". Is it offensive? Does it bring in too much of one particular religion? Why is there no corresponding song for Jewish fans? The responses don't allow room for interpretation. "Buy it or don't". ("Love it or leave it"). It speaks to the insensitivity of the song choice, but also of the fans who feel favored.
I can't even offer much of a review here myself. I purchased it, but can't bear to open the wrapping. There are pictures of all 4 of the Boys, but I believe that the whole album is mostly (if not entirely) Micky and Mike. But I hate holiday music completely. Maybe by July, it'll feel less crass.
But the idea that the Monkees would release a holiday, no-a CHRISTMAS album seems more than a little gratuitous.
And yes, I understand that the band was based on commercialism. Everyone and their brother does a Xmas album at one point, and really-wouldn't we rather hear THEM than yet another playing of "White Christmas" by Bing Crosby (or anyone else for that matter)?? But why NOW? And if they are going to do a follow up-or SERIES (??) of follow up albums to their record breaking release "Good Times" (2016), why would this one be a holiday album. Answer: because it will be purchased whether it is good or not-and lots of the hard hitting reviewers will give it a pass bc it is in the Xmas genre.
On Facebook, there have also been discussions of the track list, especially focusing on one in particular. "Jesus Christ". Is it offensive? Does it bring in too much of one particular religion? Why is there no corresponding song for Jewish fans? The responses don't allow room for interpretation. "Buy it or don't". ("Love it or leave it"). It speaks to the insensitivity of the song choice, but also of the fans who feel favored.
I can't even offer much of a review here myself. I purchased it, but can't bear to open the wrapping. There are pictures of all 4 of the Boys, but I believe that the whole album is mostly (if not entirely) Micky and Mike. But I hate holiday music completely. Maybe by July, it'll feel less crass.
No comments:
Post a Comment